Will Our Local Pastors Lead the Fight? The Rampant Abuse of Migrant Domestic Workers in our Midst

by Rose Khouri

Two months ago I arrived at the office expecting a normal day. I ended up driving a sobbing Kenyan woman to a shelter for abused migrant workers.

This young woman, terrified, crying, unable to make eye contact, is one of a quarter million guest workers – primarily women from East Africa and East/South East Asia – living and working in Lebanon. The abusive situation she was running away from is neither uncommon, nor surprising. 

Maids, nannies, and other low skilled positions in Lebanon have not always been associated with potential, or even inevitable abuse. As author Nayla Moukarbel noted, before Lebanon’s civil war, domestic workers were either poor local women, or immigrants from other Arab countries like Syria or Iraq. The families of the maids frequently had contact with their daughters’ employers, reducing the maids’ isolation and potential for exploitation. As fellow Arabs, their cultural and linguistic differences were lessened. Often the maids came to work for their employers at a young age, allowing them to develop close, almost familial ties over the years.

Once the Lebanese civil war began, Lebanese families began to switch to African or Asian maids. The rising tensions of the escalating crisis resulted in a shift from the potential sectarian threats of regional maids to non-partisan African or Asian workers. Lacking ties to divisive political parties, interfering countries, or opposing religious groups, these new maids posed no threat to the stability of the country’s political environment. However, the employer-employee relationship had been heavily altered to the detriment of the guest workers who, living far away from their families and support systems, have greater potential for abuse.[1]

Driving back to work, after spending an hour ensuring the young woman would be taken in and taken care of at the shelter while they looked into legal options, my primary emotion was not grief but anger. I was angry. I was angry that someone could abuse a woman. I was angry that a human being was being abused maybe 5 -10 minutes away from where I live. I was angry that someone from my own identity, a fellow ‘Christian’, was abusing a human being. There was no ‘Other’ that I could blame in this situation.

Lebanon is not a bad country. The Lebanese are not bad people. Lebanon has been a shelter to thousands upon thousands – Armenians, Palestinians, Syrians, Iraqis, Sudanese, etc. But we live in a world where power and privilege do not exist in absolutes but filter through layers. The oppressed can too easily oppress others.

I was angry that day. But every Sunday after I only became angrier. I have sat through many sermons in Lebanon. I have listened to pastors preach about gratefulness, about money, about how to be a good father and mother, but never once have I heard a pastor or a priest speak about the abuse of domestic workers. I have to ask, what is the point of spending an hour and a half on a sermon about how ‘good Christians shouldn’t complain’ if you know that people sitting in front of you listening intently might go home and physically abuse another human being?

Doubly frustrating is that in Lebanon people tend to hire domestic workers from the same religion. Muslim Lebanese often prefer fellow Muslims from Bangladesh, while Christian Lebanese prefer fellow Christians from the Philippines, Kenya, or Ethiopia. Are Lebanese pastors or priests responsible just for the Arabs sitting in front of them? Is their role as shepherds of our Christian community restricted to those with whom they share an ethnic tie?

Of course, this is not just a Christian issue in Lebanon – physical, sexual, and emotional abuse is happening to female guest workers in every kind of home in Lebanon. The same Lebanese Muslims who have angrily protested the crimes committed against their fellow Muslims in Palestine or Iraq have often returned home to scream at their Muslim maids from Bangladesh. A young Muslim man, who passionately posts about the treatment of Muslims in the West, once told me, “Bangladeshis are very stupid and they will try and cheat you.” But, I cannot speak for Lebanese Muslims. I can only speak to the Church of which I am part.

My challenge to the Lebanese Church is this: right now abuse is happening. It is happening in large ways (sexual, physical, and emotional abuse). It is happening in small ways (small markets will ignore guest workers and serve me first). This is not just something being committed by Other people and this is not something that is affecting communities hours and hours away from ours. The woman I drove to a shelter lived in a Christian area of Lebanon. She experienced extreme abuse while church bells called Christians to come and worship. This is an issue at the core of our Christian faith – what does God require of us but to do justice, to love kindness, and to walk humbly with Him (Micah 6:8). Where is the Lebanese Christian leadership? Where is the emphasis on education, guidance, and peacemaking? Are these not the roles of our pastors?

I am not asking the Lebanese Church to solve the Syrian crisis. I am not asking our pastors to solve poverty, broken families, homeless children, or financial instability. Rather I am asking our pastors to acknowledge what is being done behind closed doors, by members of their congregations. I am asking for them to prioritize their teachings and sermons to address this issue. Can you imagine if our Church leaders used their platforms, their voices to equip their people for works of service, so that the body of Christ might be built up until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ? (Ephesians 4:12-13)

There is so much violence, so much pain going on in our region that we cannot control. But this issue, this stain on Lebanon’s reputation as a historical safe haven, is something our community should not just address but should lead the fight against.

________________

[1] N Moukarbel, Sri Lankan Housemaids in Lebanon: A Case of ‘Symbolic Violence’ and ‘Everyday Forms of Resistance’, Amsterdam University Press, Amsterdam 2009, p 30.

5 thoughts on “Will Our Local Pastors Lead the Fight? The Rampant Abuse of Migrant Domestic Workers in our Midst

  1. Can you imagine if our Church leaders used their platforms, their voices to fight for the least of these – the domestic workers? Yes, I can imagine it.

  2. Rose, thank you. Thank you for sharing your anger & your constructive criticism, from an inclusive position. This is such sobering reading, because it reminds us how easily any of us can become color blind, blinkered while acquiescing to all the right doctrine. But sound doctrine in the pages of the NT authors ALWAYS has to do with behavior, how we live the Gospel. I pray that this will raise not only awareness, but action from whoever reads your blog, including me!

  3. Dear friends in Lebanon,

    thank you very much for all your posts and opinions, and especially for this one. The frankness, lucidity and open questions concern all Christians in the world. EMW supports some programs to combat abuse of migrant workers, especially in East Asia. Are there organizations caring for the abused workers in Lebanon? Are European Churches / mIssions helping somehow? Knowing the good work of the Baptists in Lebanon, and we ourselves working a lot with NEST, Reformed and Evangelical Churches as well as the MECC, would like to know a little bit more about this. WE can promise to promote awareness. Perhaps the discussion in Lebanon might also help address the situation in other countries, where similar problems exist, including in Europe.

    Best wishes, stay blessed !

    Rev. Dr. Owe Boersma Africa & Middle East Secretary EMW Germany.

    >

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s